OPEN LETTER TO PRESIDENT AKUFO-ADDO ON GALAMSEY

Accra, 28 September 2022

OPEN LETTER TO PRESIDENT AKUFO-ADDO ON GALAMSEY

Mr President:

The main problem with unlicensed mining in Ghana (‘Galamsey’) and the increasing scourge it has become, is the Government’s sheer inability, total unpreparedness and/or blatant unwillingness to enforce the law. We are befuddled and dumbstruck at the Government’s absolute impotence, in the face of the brazen destruction of our lands and wanton poisoning of our water bodies.

Every law required to regulate the mining industry exists. Every Government agency required to enforce the law (namely the Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources, Minerals Commission, the police, the courts and even the military) exists. Every district, municipality and metropolis in which Galamsey takes place has a fully-paid Chief Executive supported by an Authority and Assembly. There are chiefs in all of those towns and villages where the plunder happens. These people cannot feign ignorance and pretend to be innocent in this matter. What is going on defies reason and only gives support and credence to the popular rumour or belief that the very persons who should be fighting this crime, are rather those involved in and benefitting from it.

On 10 July 2017, the presidency.gov.gh website reported that you called the bluff of Galamsey operators and stated that you would put your presidency on the line for the Galamsey fight. You are reported to have added that ‘IT WILL BE A BETRAYAL OF THE TRUST IMPOSED ON ME IF I FAIL TO END THIS.’ Subsequently, you have repeated this pledge in various forms. However, your bold statements are ringing hollow and have petered out; you are failing and, in your own words, betraying the trust reposed in you. Sir, can you simply ensure that the law, namely the Minerals and Mining Act, 2006 (Act 703), as amended, is enforced without fear and favour and irrespective of whose ox is gored?

For our part, we will send a reminder to you every Monday, until we see firm action to stamp this crime out. If that fails, we will shame your Government by going to court to compel the Government to sit up and do its job! That is not a threat, sir; it is a promise.

Yours in the service of God and Country,

OccupyGhana

cc. All Media Houses

ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S ADMITS ‘INORDINATE DELAY’ AND ‘SIGNIFICANT TARDINESS’ ON DISALLOWANCE AND SURCHARGE ENFORCEMENT – OCCUPYGHANA’S RESPONSE

PRESS RELEASE

ATTORNEY-GENERAL’S ADMITS ‘INORDINATE DELAY’ AND ‘SIGNIFICANT TARDINESS’ ON DISALLOWANCE AND SURCHARGE ENFORCEMENT – OCCUPYGHANA’S RESPONSE

Accra, 29 August 2022: The Attorney-General has admitted, in his letter dated 19 July 2022 to OccupyGhana, that his office and the Auditor-General have failed to enforce disallowances and surcharges because of ‘INORDINATE DELAY’ and ‘SIGNIFICANT TARDINESS.’

This shows that both the Attorney-General and Auditor-General have breached the 2017 orders of the Supreme Court in OCCUPYGHANA v ATTORNEY-GENERAL, namely (i) the Auditor-General must disallow and surcharge whenever the circumstances listed in article 187(7) of the Constitution are triggered, and (iii) the Attorney-General must enforce disallowances and surcharges, including initiating criminal prosecution. Clearly, both offices have exhibited shocking nonchalance and contemptuous disinterestedness in the Supreme Court’s orders.

FORMER AUDITOR GENERAL’S ACTIONS
This is in contrast with the immediate aftermath of the Supreme Court decision, when the then Auditor-General enforced the Supreme Court decision and disallowed more than GHS5 Billion that the Government was falsely required to pay, and then recovered more than GHS67 Million through surcharges. Ghana thus became a worldwide beacon of the anti-corruption fight, with the World Bank acknowledging both the Supreme Court decision and these recoveries in the 2020 GLOBAL REPORT, titled Enhancing Government Effectiveness and Transparency: The Fight Against Corruption, and revealing that ‘this achievement [had] inspired other African [countries] to pass similar legislation on disallowances and surcharges.’

CURRENT AUDITOR-GENERAL’S ABJECT FAILURE
However, since the appointment of the current Auditor-General, we have noticed an inexplicable reluctance on his part to disallow and surcharge. Even when his annual reports point to the constitutional disallowance and surcharge triggers, the Auditor-General inexcusably and inexplicably refuses to issue them, contrary to the mandatory demands by the Constitution and the Supreme Court. OccupyGhana’s consistent reminders to the Auditor-General of his obligations under the Constitution, with potential consequences of him being held in contempt of court, and/or prosecution for a high crime under the Constitution, fell on deaf ears.

AUDITOR-GENERAL’S EXCUSE CREATES A LOOPHOLE FOR CULPRITS
It was well over a year of writing, and after a petition to the Right to Information Commission, that the Auditor-General responded to OccupyGhana’s queries, to shockingly admit that since he took office, he has only issued ONE disallowance and surcharge. He explains that he is now investigating the matters in his own annual reports, to gather evidence for disallowance and surcharge.

This excuse is not just ridiculous and farcical; it is false and contrived. Here is an Auditor-General who has published several reports in which he cites the constitutional triggers for disallowance and surcharge, names the possible culprits and states the amounts lost to Ghana. He has submitted those reports to Parliament. But his excuse for not exercising his constitutional duties is that he only investigates for evidence to disallow and surcharge, after he has submitted and published the reports. In effect, the reports notify potential culprits and give them the opportunity to cover their tracks up and possibly destroy evidence.


OCCUPYGHANA CHASES ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR ENFORCEMENT
OccupyGhana also wrote to the Attorney-General, demanding what steps that his office had taken to enforce the Auditor-General’s disallowances and surcharges, when issued. Again, it took over a year and finally a petition to the Right to Information Commission to get the Attorney-General to respond.
When the Attorney-General finally responded, on 19 July 2022, his response catalogued and revealed a generally failed and unacceptable state of enforcement as follows:

(1) 2017 and 2018: no enforcement occurred because the Auditor-General failed to provide required follow-up information;
(2) 2019 and 2020: no record of enforcement; and
(3) 2021: the Attorney-General’s office received just ONE notice of surcharge; however, ‘there has been a rather inordinate delay in the institution of the action… [and we are] now ready to file the suit and will do so immediately.’

OCCUPYGHANA’S NEXT STEPS
We are concerned that the Auditor-General pays little to scant attention to the obligations placed upon him by law. For instance, although he is required by article 187(5) of the Constitution to submit his reports to Parliament ‘within six months after the end of the immediately preceding financial year,’ and by section 23 of the Audit Service Act to publish them ‘as soon as the reports have been presented to the Speaker,’ it was only a letter from OccupyGhana to him dated 24 August 2022 (our ref OG/2022/028), that compelled him to surreptitiously publish some of the 2021 reports on the Audit Service website.

In the coming weeks, we intend to escalate our engagement with both the Auditor-General and Attorney-General to ensure that the proper thing is done. If they fail to comply, we would have no other choice but to return to court. However, we invite Ghanaians to join us in this fight. We do not need to incur further legal expenses just to get public officers to do the work that both the Constitution and the Supreme Court have already ordered them to do.
-END-

OCCUPYGHANA ENGAGES LANDS MINISTRY AND LANDS COMMISSION ON CONCERNS OVER PUBLIC LANDS

23 August 2022

PRESS RELEASE

OCCUPYGHANA ENGAGES LANDS MINISTRY AND LANDS COMMISSION ON CONCERNS OVER PUBLIC LANDS

Accra, 23 August 2022: On 11 August 2022, OccupyGhana met with officials of the Ministry of Lands and Natural Resources, members of the Ministry’s Advisory Board and officials of the Lands Commission. The meeting was held at the instance of the Ministry’s Advisory Board to discuss OccupyGhana’s concerns over alleged returns of Public Lands to alleged pre-acquisition owners.

This followed OccupyGhana’s incessant inquiries following the Achimota Forest Lands saga. OccupyGhana has specifically demanded that the Lands Commission and the Ministry produce the legal basis and Policy Directive governing these returns. This meeting was held after both the Ministry and Lands Commission responded in writing to candidly concede that there is no such Policy Directive in place.

At the meeting, chaired by a Co-Chair of the Ministry’s Advisory Board, OccupyGhana asked why the Government, although it was under no legal compulsion to do so, would take Public Lands that belong to all Ghanaians, and return them to alleged pre-acquisition owners for next to nothing, only for the lands to end up in the hands of the rich and government officials.

OccupyGhana also stated its view that these transactions breached both the President’s constitutionally imposed duties as the trustee of all Public Lands on behalf of all the people of Ghana (under article 257 of the Constitution), and the Lands Commission’s constitutionally imposed fiduciary and accountability duties (under article 36(8) of the Constitution.) We repeated our further view that the direct involvement of the Government in these matters, instead of issuing ‘general directions in writing to the Lands Commission on matters of policy in respect of the functions of the Commission,’ is also a breach of the autonomy of the Lands Commission in land management matters (under articles 258 and 265 of the Constitution.)
OccupyGhana finally reiterated that it stood by all of its demands in the several letters to the Minister and Lands Commission, including (i) full disclosure of all such transactions since the Constitution came into force, (ii) a public inquiry into them, (iii) a freeze of all pending returns (including the Achimota Forest), and (iv) the issuance of a Policy Directive by Government, so that Ghanaians, who are the beneficiaries of those lands, can raise questions about and challenge the policy.

TAKE OUT FROM MEETING

Lands Commission is still compiling the information of all returns of Public Lands from the regions and will submit that to OccupyGhana when it is ready.

Within one month, the Lands Commission will draft the Policy Directives and submit them to the Ministry to consider for adoption.

Lands Commission will, before sending the draft policies to the Ministry, engage all stakeholders, including OccupyGhana, in working on and reviewing the draft policies.

Lands Commission is very concerned about private encroachment of Public Lands and would want OccupyGhana’s advocacy to also focus on that matter.

CONCLUDING COMMENTS

While OccupyGhana appreciates the opportunity to have met with and express our concerns to officials, we remain deeply concerned about the current state of affairs and the admission that after almost 30 years of the coming into force of this Constitution, there is no Policy Directive on the management of Public Lands in Ghana. The effect of this is that we have an opaque, ad-hoc system, which in itself is unconstitutional. We remain resolute that there must be a freeze of every planned return of Public Lands until the entire system has been reviewed by a duly constituted Commission of Inquiry, and the constitutionally required and relevant Policy Directives have been put in place.

OccupyGhana is also concerned that while section 13 of the new Land Act criminalises the breach of the fiduciary and accountability duties by managers of stool, skin and family lands, the Act stops short of specifically criminalising the same breach by managers of Public Lands. This is especially shocking because article 36(8) of the Constitution imposes the same duties on all ‘managers of public, stool, skin and family lands.’ Thus, the selective criminalisation in the Land Act is discriminatory, wrong and therefore unconstitutional. Our view is that the list of specific crimes that public officers may commit under section 277 of the Land Act, does not cover the breach of their fiduciary and accountability duties. We therefore call for the amendment of section 13 of the Land Act to bring in managers of Public Lands, because the universal criminalisation of these breaches will make public officials more careful and circumspect in the performing their duties relating to the management and disposal of Public Lands.
-END-

GHANA’S CURRENT TRIP TO THE IMF IS A CRYING SHAME

Like almost all Ghanaians, it had been blindingly obvious to us for a while that the Government would have to return to the IMF. Yet, not even that foreknowledge could describe the disappointment when Government made the formal announcement. This return is spectacularly remarkable because it is after we boldly announced the ‘Ghana Without Aid’ aspiration.

FISCAL RESPONSIBILITY ACT

When the 2018 Fiscal Responsibility Act was passed, we were concerned whether that Act would indeed impose the kind of fiscal responsibility and discipline that Ghana needed. We therefore wrote a detailed letter to the Finance Minister on 29 January 2019, to inquire which steps were being taken to ensure that there was real control of excessive government expenditure. We received neither a response nor even a simple acknowledgement of receipt.

E-LEVY

It was clear to everyone that the E-Levy was not going to be the panacea to Ghana’s problem. We issued a press statement on 15 February 2022, in which we questioned the loftily utopian expectations, and stated that ‘the e-levy will be meaningless until it is linked with (1) the total implementation of our income tax laws, (2) absolute commitment to recovering our misused monies, and (3) complete fiscal transparency and accountability.’ Although we delivered copies of the statement to both the Executive and Parliament, that was also ignored.

WHY DO WE NEED IMF SUPPORT?

We have noted from the statement of the Information Minister, that Ghana would be seeking about $2B from the IMF. $2B is roughly ₡16B. Is that ALL we need to tide us over the mess that we find ourselves in? And do we have to go scurrying to the IMF to provide that, when from the Auditor-General’s Reports, calculated from 2016 to 2020, the amount of monies lost or stolen is ₡47,945,579,875? In dollar terms, that is almost three times the $2B we are going for.

Clearly, we would not need the IMF if the government was serious about recovering these lost and stolen monies, and then plugging the holes that allowed them to be lost or stolen in the first place.

DISALLOWANCE & SURCHARGE

Mercifully, the framers of our Constitution had sufficient foresight on these matters and therefore entrusted the Auditor-General to, beyond merely conducting audits and producing journalistic reports, disallow wrongful expenditure and surcharge people who either cause losses or steal our monies.

Also, the 2000 Audit Service Act specifically empowered the Attorney-General to take legal action to recover the monies, where the persons surcharged do not pay after 60 days.

Yet, for almost 25 years after the Constitution came into force, these fine laws simply adorned the pages of our statute books, and neither the government nor the Auditor-General took any step to enforce them.

What we were subjected to was the annual charade where the Auditor-General issued lame and tame Reports, did no disallowance or surcharge, and then passed the baton to Parliament’s inaptly named Public Accounts Committee to continue the charade with televised hearings that did not recover a pesewa of the lost or stolen funds.

SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT

It had to take OccupyGhana, formed only in 2014, to go to the Supreme Court to teach the Auditor-General how to read and understand the simple powers that the Constitution had vested in that office. Thankfully, the judiciary in June 2017, threw out all the defences that the government put up against our case, including the insultingly fatuous and risible objection that we did not have the capacity to take the government to court. The judiciary also ignored the blatantly false claim by the then Auditor-General that its Management Letters constituted the disallowances and surcharges that the Constitution demanded.

Ghana’s judiciary stood up for Ghana when it unanimously ordered both the Auditor-General and the Attorney-General to do what is mandatorily required of them by both the Constitution and the Audit Service Act.

RECOVERIES MADE

As if by divine providence, this development coincided with the appointment of a new Auditor-General who was prepared to act on the judgment. As the President acknowledged in his 2015 State of the Nation Address, the first act of disallowance by the Auditor-General stopped the potential theft of ₡5.4B (which at that date was roughly $1B) by public officials. And as the Vice President acknowledged in a speech during a Town Hall Meeting on 3 April 2019, the Auditor-General had by that date issued disallowance and surcharge certificates in excess of ₡500M and succeeded in recovering almost ₡70M in lost or stolen funds.

Although not a single public official or other person got prosecuted for any of these, the pleasing aspects of these developments in Ghana caught the eye of the World Bank. In its 2020 GLOBAL REPORT, titled ENHANCING GOVERNMENT EFFECTIVENESS AND TRANSPARENCY: THE FIGHT AGAINST CORRUPTION, the World Bank proudly mentioned the June 2017 OccupyGhana judgment and stated that these achievements in Ghana had inspired the enactment of ‘similar legislation on disallowances and surcharges’ elsewhere. We know that Uganda, Sierra Leone, Kenya, Zambia and South Africa, have passed laws that take inspiration from our disallowance and surcharge laws.

GOVERNMENT SHENANIGANS

However, Ghana’s role as the poster child in this matter was to suffer a severe jolt with the government’s shenanigans that forced the immediate past Auditor-General out of office. Two cases filed around the same time to determine the extent of the Auditor-General’s independence as provided under the Constitution, have simply stalled. They are not being listed for hearing, despite considerable pressure from civil society.

RETURN OF THE CHARADE

The result is that the charade has returned. The current Auditor-General is clearly scared to exercise the disallowance and surcharge powers. After months of pressure from OccupyGhana, the Auditor-General now claims that he has issued just ONE surcharge since the 2018 Reports were published.

His weak explanation is that after he issues his Reports listing the losses and thefts, he then investigates to gather evidence for surcharging. If the Auditor-General is now gathering evidence, then on what basis did he issue the Reports in the first place? It is only in Ghana that the cart can pull the horse and the tail can wag the dog in such a brazenly inexplicable manner.

The Attorney-General is not left out in this charade. Apart from being required by law and the Supreme Court to take steps to recover the lost and stolen monies, he is required by the 2016 Public Financial Management Act to submit reports on these steps.

However, he has ignored all our requests for information (spanning a full year) on whether he has prepared and submitted these reports, finally compelling us to file a petition against him with the Right to Information Commission on 30 June 2022. We await the Commission’s ruling.

IMF, THE BITTER TASTE…

That is why this return to the IMF for a ‘paltry’ $2B leaves a bitter taste in our mouths. We would not be submitting ourselves to this forced and humiliating ‘Ghana [is not yet] beyond aid’ position if we had prevented the losses and thefts in the first place. In the second place, we would not be here if we had taken the simple steps of recovering the monies lost and stolen.

How credible is this return to the IMF, when the monies we seek, sit comfortably in the bank accounts and pockets of those who caused us to lose the monies or who stole our monies?

DEMANDS

We strongly demand that the Auditor-General immediately resumes disallowances and surcharges.

We strongly demand that the Attorney-General enforces the disallowances and surcharges, including taking criminal action, as also demanded by the Supreme Court.

A nation that will not prevent or recover its lost and stolen monies, will keep making return trips to the IMF.

Yours in the service of God and Country,

OccupyGhana

RE: REQUEST FOR INFORMATION CONCERNING RELEASED/RELINQUISHED LANDS

30 June 2022

The Ag Executive Secretary
Lands Commission
Accra

Attention: James E K Dadson

Dear Sir:

RE: REQUEST FOR INFORMATION CONCERNING RELEASED/RELINQUISHED LANDS

We have received your letter dated 29 June 2022 (ref SCR/LCS3/V.7/2) on the above matter. We deeply appreciate your confirmation that you will provide us with the information we require. We also appreciate your point that your officers have to manually go through files to compile data on the information we seek, and that the various Regional Lands Commissions are working on this matter. We further appreciate your assurance that once the information is ready, you will provide it to us.

We must however respectfully draw your attention to item #6 of our list of demands in our letter dated 2 June 2022, ref OG/2022/007, which was:

‘A copy of any existing written Ministerial policy direction to the Lands Commission on these and other related matters.‘

We believe that if such a written Ministerial policy direction exists, you could send that to us right now, while we wait for the rest of the information. Kindly confirm the existence or otherwise of such a written Ministerial policy, and if it exists, kindly provide it to us at your earliest convenience.

And concerning the rest of the information we seek, we will send you a reminder a week from today, and every week thereafter, to check on the status of the efforts to procure the information for us.

Yours in the service of God and Country

OccupyGhana

cc. The Executive Secretary
Right to Information Commission
Accra

REQUEST FOR INFORMATION – MINISTERIAL POLICY DIRECTIVE ON RELEASE OR RELINQUISHING OF PUBLIC LANDS

30 June 2022

The Minister
Ministry of Lands & Natural Resources
Accra

Dear Sir,

REQUEST FOR INFORMATION – MINISTERIAL POLICY DIRECTIVE ON RELEASE OR RELINQUISHING OF PUBLIC LANDS

Since the coming into force of the Fourth Republican Constitution on 7 January 1993, several parcels of public lands have been released from government ownership or control. These include lands that the government had acquired over the years through outright purchases, statutory vesting, compulsory acquisition or the constitutional freehold reversionary interest under article 266 of the Constitution.

We are interested in the circumstances surrounding the release or relinquishing of these lands. We therefore request, in the exercise of our right to information under article 21 of the Constitution, for the following:

  1. Whether there exists any written Ministerial Policy Direction to the Lands Commission on these matters, issued under article 258(2) of the Constitution; and, if so
  2. A copy of that written Ministerial policy direction.

We look forward to hearing from you shortly.

Yours in the service of God and Country

OccupyGhana

cc. The Information Officer
Ministry of Lands & Natural Resources
Accra

The Executive Secretary
Right to Information Commission
Accra

Re: FINAL DEMAND TO ISSUE DISALLOWANCES AND SURCHARGES

1 July 2022

The Auditor-General
Office of the Auditor-General
Ministry Block ‘O’
P O Box M 96
Accra (GA-110-8787)

Dear Sir,

Re: FINAL DEMAND TO ISSUE DISALLOWANCES AND SURCHARGES

We refer to our letter to you dated 21 June 2022 on the above matter (our ref: OG/2022/010) (enclosed), and particularly the following demand contained in that letter:

‘Kindly provide us with the following information:

  1. full details of that disallowance and surcharge certificate (including a copy of it)
  2. evidence of service of the certificate on the person surcharged,
  3. the date on which you transmitted the certificate to the Attorney-General,
  4. any evidence of steps taken by the Attorney-General on the matter.’

You have neither acknowledged receipt of that letter nor sent us the required information. Kindly send us that information at your earliest convenience.

Yours in the service of God and Country,

OccupyGhana

cc. The Executive Secretary
Right to Information Commission
Accra

The Attorney-General & Minister of Justice
Office of the Attorney-General and Ministry of Justice
Accra

ALL MEDIA HOUSES

Enc.

RIGHT TO INFORMATION REQUEST

30 June 2022

The Executive Secretary
Right to Information Commission
Accra

Dear Sir:

RIGHT TO INFORMATION REQUEST

OccupyGhana is a good governance pressure group, registered as a guarantee company under the laws of the Republic of Ghana, and all of whose members and executive are citizens of Ghana.

In 2016, Parliament passed the Public Financial Management Act, 2016 (Act 921) to ‘to regulate the financial management of the public sector within a macroeconomic and fiscal framework, to define responsibilities of persons entrusted with the management and control of public funds, assets, liabilities and resources, to ensure that public funds are sustainable and consistent with the level of public debt, to provide for accounting and audit of public funds and to provide for related matters.’

In line with this preamble, section 85(2) of Act 921 imposed an obligation on the Attorney General to, upon the release of the Auditor-General’s Annual Reports and recommendations of Parliament’s Public Accounts Committee, take action and submit an annual report on the status of any such action to the Finance Minister, Auditor-General and Parliament.

Additionally, the Supreme Court has affirmed the Attorney-General’s obligation to take action on the Auditor-General’s reports in OCCUPYGHANA v ATTORNEY-GENERAL [2017-2018] 2 SCLRG 527 at 568, as follows: ‘the Attorney-General is hereby ordered to take all necessary steps to enforce the decisions or steps taken by the Auditor-General supra to ensure compliance including in some cases criminal prosecutions.’

On 30 June 2021, we wrote a letter (ref OG/2021/002) to the Office of the Attorney-General requesting information on whether or not the Office had complied with section 85(2) of Act 921. However, the Office ignored this request. On 7 June 2022, we wrote a follow up letter (ref OG/2022/008) to the Office, which has also been ignored.

As citizens of Ghana, we are interested in ascertaining whether these demands of the Act and the orders of the Supreme Court are being met. We therefore request, in line with article 21(1)(f) of the Constitution and section 18 of the Right to Information Act, 2019 (Act 989), that the Commission compels the Attorney-General to make available to us:
(1) a list of all actions or steps that the Attorney-General has taken since:

(a) 2016 when Act 921 was passed, and

(b) 2017 when the Supreme Court decision was made;

(2) the status of all such actions or steps as at the date of this letter, and

(3) copies of:

(a) the annual reports that the Attorney-General has submitted in line with section 85(2) of Act 921, and

(b) actions and processes taken pursuant to the Supreme Court decision.

We would appreciate it if the information is delivered to us in hard copy and/or electronic form, and we are happy to provide the necessary computer drives for the electronic format.

We have attached copies of our letters dated 30 June 2021 and 7 June 2022 requesting the above information from the Attorney-General for your ease of reference.

We look forward to receiving the information requested.

Yours in the service of God and Country,

OccupyGhana

Enc.

cc. Attorney-General & Minister of Justice
Office of the Attorney General & Ministry of Justice
Accra

Speaker of Parliament
Parliament House
Accra

Minister for Finance
Accra

Auditor-General
Accra

The Information Officer
Office of the Attorney General & Ministry of Justice
Accra